Lords call for Flood Re-style safety net for cyber as they warn UK is unready for cascading crises

Peers say business has been left on the fringes of national resilience planning, calling for cheaper insurance for prepared firms and finance-style tests
Lords call for Flood Re-style safety net for cyber as they warn UK is unready for cascading crises
CYBER
By Stephen Owens
16 Nov 2026

Peers have urged the government to keep Flood Re running beyond 2039 and use the same public-private model to help insure the UK against large-scale cyberattacks, in a report accusing ministers of complacency over risks that could prove catastrophic.

The House of Lords national resilience committee published Are we ready? Building a culture of resilience earlier today, following an inquiry that began taking evidence in March. Its central charge is that emergency plans are largely out of date – built around single events such as a power cut, extreme weather or a cyberattack, rather than the reality of one crisis triggering the next.

If a cyberattack takes down part of the power grid, trains stop, water pumping falters and lorries cannot reach distribution centres; within days, supermarket shelves begin to empty. The committee wants ministers to plan for that entire domino run, rather than its individual tiles.

For an industry that prices risk on the assumption that most losses do not land at once, correlated, cascading events are the primary concern keeping reinsurers and cyber underwriters awake at night.

A backstop for cyber

The committee’s insurance recommendations are unusually specific for a parliamentary report. It wants Flood Re – the state-backed flood reinsurance scheme – extended beyond its planned 2039 end date, and its model adapted to provide “more effective cover for risks that are difficult to insure, including large-scale cyberattacks”. Ministers should also ensure businesses of all sizes understand how insurance can limit the financial damage of a breach.

The proposals will be welcomed by an insurance market that has spent years lobbying for a government-backed cyber backstop, frequently pointing to Pool Re, the terrorism reinsurer established in 1993, as a template. The British Insurance Brokers’ Association (Biba) included a UK cyber backstop in its 2026 manifesto, though ministers have so far shown little appetite for the idea.

Read next: The insurability test that 9/11 invented is being run again - this time on cyber and AI

Written evidence from the Association of British Insurers (ABI) underlined the scale of the threat. Its members paid out £197m to help businesses recover from cyber incidents in 2024, up 230% on the previous year. The trade body warned that smaller firms routinely underestimate their exposure – citing government data showing half of UK SMEs faced a cyberattack in 2025 – and noted that take-up of cyber and terrorism cover among smaller businesses remains low.

The broker Howden went further, citing research indicating that 60% of SMEs without cyber cover go bankrupt within six months of a severe incident.

Not every witness viewed insurance as a panacea. Oliver Neuberger of Accenture described cyber cover as a “financial mitigation mechanism” that cannot protect against reputational damage or indirect losses. Its greater value, he argued, lies in the minimum security standards insurers insist upon before underwriting a policy.

Read next: Flood Re warns 2039 transition hinges on faster risk reduction

Business ‘on the fringes’

Peers warned that while the private sector must be integrated into national resilience planning, businesses currently “sit on the fringes” – even though more than 80% of the UK’s critical national infrastructure is privately owned and maintained.

Rather than a blanket mandate, the committee proposed a three-tier framework modelled on Finland’s security-of-supply system. Firms essential to national resilience would face statutory preparedness and continuity duties alongside regular stress tests. A second tier would have resilience requirements written into government contracts. All other businesses, including SMEs, would receive practical guidance and financial incentives, including tax reliefs and cheaper insurance for those that comply.

The committee also wants financial-style stress testing applied to critical infrastructure, with regular cross-sector exercises covering food, energy, water and pharmaceuticals – a model familiar to insurers subjected to the Prudential Regulation Authority’s exercises, which recently found the sector’s resilience had strengthened.

Ministers, however, remain resistant to new regulation. Giving evidence to the committee, the minister Angela Eagle said the government still prefers voluntary action by business over statutory duties.

Read next: The ABI just made the case for commercial brokers to government

The insurance sector has been pressing for closer integration for some time. Last year, the ABI’s director general, Hannah Gurga, used the ABI’s annual dinner to call for insurers to be embedded at the heart of resilience planning. Over the summer, the ABI pushed for insurers to be brought into major infrastructure projects before key decisions are locked in.

The committee’s headline structural recommendation is a dedicated cabinet minister for resilience, supported by a chief resilience officer at permanent secretary level and an annual statement to parliament delivered by the prime minister. Axa UK has long campaigned for a standalone resilience minister, renewing its call after subsidence claims climbed.

“We need urgent action to connect our plans, protect essential services and make preparedness part of everyday life,” said the committee’s chair, Baroness Coussins.

Attacks below the threshold

The threats highlighted by peers extend well beyond extreme weather. The report notes warnings from the head of MI5 that artificial intelligence is supercharging risks ranging from cyberattacks to biological weapons. It also accuses ministers of failing to give the public a clear picture of how frequently Russia, China and Iran target the UK below the threshold of open conflict – through cyberattacks, proxy violence and threats to undersea cables and pipelines.

Those warnings echo recent assessments from the intelligence services. The National Cyber Security Centre’s 2026 annual review logged 1,831 reports of attacks on UK organisations in the year to August, and judged it highly likely that AI-powered malware will be used in a ransomware attack on critical national infrastructure by 2028.

The review estimates the annual cost of cyberattacks to UK organisations at £14.7bn. For underwriters, the primary concern is aggregation: a single flaw in widely used software, or one attack on shared infrastructure, can hit thousands of policyholders simultaneously.

Read next: NCSC warns of ‘unprecedented’ rise in cyber incidents, even as serious breaches fall

From just-in-time to just-in-case

Some of the report’s sharpest warnings focus on fragile supply chains. Peers said they were shocked to learn that the UK imports 80% of the active ingredient for penicillin from China, alongside a large proportion of other antibiotics. The country’s last domestic antibiotics plant closed in 2025.

Food supply is similarly concentrated, with just nine retailers accounting for roughly 94.5% of groceries sold through UK supermarkets. The committee urged ministers to diversify supply chains for medicines, food and water, shifting national planning from a “just-in-time” model to a “just-in-case” approach.

For commercial underwriters, that concentration highlights how a client’s true exposure often sits several links down a supply chain it neither owns nor controls – gaps that typically surface only after a disruption triggers contingent business interruption claims.

Read next: Few UK firms quantify their disruption risk, Aon finds

The peers also recommended scrapping plans to switch off digital terrestrial television, arguing that traditional aerials and sets – which operate without broadband – would remain the most reliable way to reach the public if internet infrastructure failed.

‘A step in the right direction’

The report credited the government for launching its Be Ready campaign on 22 October, which urges households to stockpile enough water, food and essentials to last three days. While peers welcomed the initiative – the first stage of a three-year push – as a step in the right direction, they warned it was nowhere near enough on its own.

They called for a preparedness booklet to be sent to every household, a multilingual emergency app, and resilience skills to be taught from primary school through to adult education. Ministers, the committee argued, must be more candid about the threats facing the country, insisting honesty is more likely to build public trust than spark panic.

The government updated its own threat assessment over the summer, adding cyberattacks on data, water and police infrastructure to the National Risk Register 2026.

Read next: UK adds AI-driven cyber and democratic interference risks to National Risk Register

Yet peers noted that many of their warnings mirror those made by a previous Lords committee in December 2021, which published Preparing for Extreme Risks: Building a Resilient Society.

A Cabinet Office spokesperson said the government would carefully review the report, pointing to the Be Ready campaign, a major home defence exercise planned for next year and more than £1bn invested in pandemic preparedness. “Our resilience work already goes further than previous governments, while we accept there is still more to do,” they added.

What it means for brokers

None of the committee’s proposals is law, and ministers have committed only to a review. Still, the regulatory trajectory is clear: corporate resilience is shifting from a boardroom aspiration toward a benchmark that critical firms may soon be compelled to prove – and that insurers may financially reward elsewhere.

For commercial brokers, the report offers clear prompts for client reviews: testing how businesses would survive three days without power, payment systems or deliveries; checking whether business interruption policies cover vulnerabilities deep within supply chains; and ensuring clients carry adequate cyber cover. If insurers begin offering discounted premiums to firms that can prove their preparedness, clients who act early will be first in line.

Read next: Britain now ground zero for Russian cyberattacks

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB UK.