A bill introduced in the Texas Senate proposes replacing the state's insurance commissioner with a three-member Texas Commission of Insurance.
Senate Bill 1642 outlines that the commission, like the current commissioner role, would be appointed by the governor with Senate approval.
The proposed commission would consist of three members: one with regulatory expertise, a consumer advocacy specialist, and an insurance administration expert. The governor would appoint one member as the presiding officer for a two-year term, with no member permitted to serve in that role more than once within a six-year period.
Commission members would also be barred from running for elected office during their tenure.
If the bill is enacted, the governor would have until Dec. 1 to appoint the initial commission members. The panel would serve staggered six-year terms, with one member initially serving for two years, another for four years, and the third for six years.
The insurance commissioner will remain in office until the Senate confirms the new commission members. If a commission seat becomes vacant, the commissioner will serve in that position until a replacement is appointed.
If adopted, Texas would become the only state to regulate its insurance industry through a commission rather than a single commissioner, according to the National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies.
In the United States, the regulation of the insurance industry is primarily managed at the state level, with each state adopting its own framework. This typically involves either a single insurance commissioner or an insurance commission (a panel or board).
With the current model of a single commissioner, experts note that centralized leadership can lead to swift decision-making and clear accountability. However, it also places substantial responsibility on one person, which can be a point of concern if controversies arise.
Eleven states elect their insurance commissioners, while 39 states appoint them, according to data from Ballotpedia.
In most states, the insurance commissioner is part of the executive branch, with their office established either by the state constitution or by statute.
Several states have made moves to overhaul their insurance regulatory bodies.
In March last year, California Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara announced a comprehensive set of regulatory reforms aimed at overhauling Proposition 103, which has been the foundation of California's insurance regulations for over three decades. These reforms are intended to modernize the regulatory framework to better address current market challenges and consumer needs.
In November 2024, Republican James Brown was elected as the state's new insurance commissioner. Brown has expressed a commitment to "small government principles," which may indicate potential shifts in regulatory approaches.
What are your thoughts on this story? Please feel free to share your comments below.
